Harry Emerson Fosdick Preaches "Shall the Fundamentalists Win?"
Search Timelines:

Harry Emerson Fosdick
Time Period
On May 21, 1922, Harry Emerson Fosdick fired a shot across the bow of fundamentalist Presbyterians with his sermon "Shall the Fundamentalists Win?" delivered at First Presbyterian Church in New York City. Accusing fundamentalists of being "essentially illiberal and intolerant," Fosdick's minced no words in defending the new, modern theology and disputing traditional doctrines like the virgin birth of Christ, the inerrancy of the Bible, and Christ's substitutionary atonement on the cross. The sermon is unusual in that regard; few Protestant pastors in the early 1920s openly stated modernist doctrines to their often more conservative parishioners.

In response, Presbyterian fundamentalists forced Fosdick to resign his pastorate in order to escape a formal trial in 1924. The incident made Fosdick a martyr to the liberal faction of mainline Christianity, but he quickly found a new home at Park Avenue Baptist Church and a new friend in John D. Rockefeller Jr.
Interactive Timeline(s)
Presbyterian Religious Events and People in American History
Browse Related Timeline Entries
Presbyterian Religious Events and People in American History
Religious Groups
Timeline Entries for the same religious group Independent Fundamentalist Family
Independent Fundamentalist Family: Other ARDA Links

Presbyterian-Reformed Family: Other ARDA Links

Fosdick, Harry Emerson
Christian Modernism

'Shall the Fundamentalists Win' title page- Internet Archive

Harry Fosdick portrait- Library of Congress- Courtesy of the Special Collections Department University of Iowa Libraries

First Presbyterian Church, New York City- Internet Archive- from The Services in celebration of the Two Hundredth Anniversary of the founding of the Old First Presbyterian Church in the city of New York
Book/Journal Source(s)
Miller, Robert Moats, 1985. Harry Emerson Fosdick: Preacher, Pastor, Prophet. New York: Oxford University Press.
Web Source(s)
The full text of Fosdick's sermon is available here.
Web Page Contributor
Paul Matzko
Affliated with: Pennsylvania State University, Ph.D. in History

Bookmark and Share